Vol. 7 No. 6 (2026): November 2026
Open Access
Peer Reviewed

Analysis of Causes and Risk Mitigation for Delivery Delays Based on On-Time In-Full (OTIF) Data in Non-Cement Distribution Using RCA and FMEA Methods at PT XYZ

Authors

Rifki Putra Rahmadhan , Akhmad Wasiur Rizqi

DOI:

10.46729/ijstm.v7i6.1522

Published:

2026-11-14

Downloads

Abstract

Delivery punctuality is an important indicator of logistics service performance, yet non-cement distribution at PT XYZ still experiences delays. On Time In Full (OTIF) data from May to July 2026 recorded that only 54.64% of 14,986 shipments were delivered on time. This study aims to determine the on-time delivery rate, identify the dominant causes and root causes of delay, and determine mitigation priorities. The methods used were Pareto diagram, Root Cause Analysis (RCA) with fishbone and 5 Why, and Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA), with Severity, Occurrence, and Detection rated by two respondents. The Pareto results show that long parking time (49.9%) and unloading schedule (41.1%) caused 91.0% of the delays. RCA identified the root causes as the absence of a standard maximum stopping time, a joint arrival scheduling mechanism with receivers, a procedure for communicating estimated arrival, and a cargo readiness confirmation procedure. Based on FMEA, the highest Risk Priority Number (RPN) belongs to the absence of a joint arrival scheduling mechanism with receivers (336), followed by the absence of an estimated arrival notification procedure (168) and a standard maximum stopping time (120). Joint arrival scheduling with receivers should be the priority for improvement.

Keywords:

On Time In Full, Root Cause Analysis, Failure Mode and Effect Analysis and Pareto.

References

[1] Adianto, H., & Herawati, N. (2024). Analysis of Production Time Improvement to Achieve On-Time Results and Delivery to Customers. 2024.

[2] Anggraeni, A., & Fety Nurlia Muzayanah. (2025). Analysis of Total Quality Management with RCA and FMEA at XYZ Community Health Center, Indramayu. Mamen: Journal of Management, 4(3), 328–342. https://Doi.Org/10.55123/Mamen.V4i3.5439

[3] Dinda Nurhalizah Mawardy, A., & Kirono, I. (2026). Process Evaluation of Package Delivery Delays at the Branch Office of PT Xyz Logistics & Services Company (Vol. 10). https://Jurnal.Ustjogja.Ac.Id/Index.Php/Manajemendewantara

[4] Fatah, KMA, Lukman, I., Sidiq, A., & Wardhana, MW (2025). Analysis of the Causes of Delays in Delivery of Cardboard Sheet Products Using the FMEA Method and Recommended Solutions in the Cardboard Sheet Industry. Journal of Engineering, Technology, and Science, 9(2), 803–810. https://Doi.Org/10.33024/Jrets.V9i2.21518

[5] Firdausy, MF, & Koes Ardhiyanto, N. (2025). Risk Mitigation in the Biodiesel Supply Chain in Java Island Using Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Root Cause Analysis (RCA) Methods. In Marsha Fazira Firdausy, Sntem (Vol. 5).

[6] Kumala Dewi, N., Ariffien, A., Gustamola, W., & Son Seran, D. (2026). Analysis of Factors of Delayed Delivery of Goods and Implications for Continuous Improvement. https://Doi.Org/10./Idealogist.

[7] Luthfi Firdaus, R., Hapsak Pradipto, G., & Teknik Industri, J. (2026). Analysis of the Causes of Delivery Delays at Indah Logistik Cargo (Ilc) Pilar Agents Using the DMAIC Method. Journal of Applied Industrial Technology and Management (Jtmit), 5(2), 1111–1121.

[8] Nelfiyanti. (2024). Analysis of Product Delivery Delay Factors to Consumers Using the FMEA Method at PT.Mrp.

[9] Nur Cahyani, A., & Hanif Dzulquarnain, A. (2025). Analysis of the Modern Retail Shipping Process at a Distributor Company in Gresik Using Root Cause Analysis. 6, 2027.

[10] Petty Wahyuningtyas, N., Eka Ratnawati, D., & Yudi Setiawan, N. (2023). Sentiment-Based Root Cause Analysis (RCA) Using the K-Nearest Neighbor (K-NN) Method (Case Study: Brawijaya Swimming Pool Visitors) (Vol. 7, Number 5). Http://J-Ptiik.Ub.Ac.Id

[11] Pradipa, R. (2025). Analysis and Identification of Factors Affecting On Time In Full (OTIF) Performance at PT X Using the Creative Dmaic Method, Jakarta 2025.

[12] Rizki, M., & Saputra, A. (2022). Supply Chain Management Risk Analysis Using Grey Failure Mode and Effect Analysis and Root Cause Analysis Methods at PT Pertamina Fuel Terminal Meulaboh. Serambi Engineering, Vii(1).

[13] Sholikhah, FA, Darmawan, H., Prastyo, Y., & Industri, JT (2026). Application of Root Cause Analysis (RCA) and Plan, Do, Check, Action (PDCA) Methods to Reduce Deadstock Value in Spare Part Warehouses. Journal of Applied Industrial Technology and Management (JTMIT), 5(3), 1221–1229.

[14] Soleman, Zaenal, & Vera. (2026). Analysis of Product Defect Causes Using the RCA and FMEA Methods to Reduce Defects in the Assembly Process. Journal of Engineering Management and Business Innovation, 4 (February), 67–74. https://doi.org/10.62375/jmrib.v4i2.828

[15] Zuhrotul Baida, A., & Herwanto, D. (2025). Analysis Of Factors Causing Non-Compatibility Of Label Stock Using The 5 Why And Fishbone Diagram Method In The Food And Beverage Industry.

Author Biographies

Rifki Putra Rahmadhan, Program Studi Teknik Industri, Fakultas Teknik, Universitas Muhammadiyah Gresik, Jalan Sumatera No.101, Gresik Kota Baru (GKB) , Kabupaten Gresik , Jawa Timur, 61121, Indonesia

Author Origin : Indonesia

Akhmad Wasiur Rizqi, Program Studi Teknik Industri, Fakultas Teknik, Universitas Muhammadiyah Gresik, Jalan Sumatera No.101, Gresik Kota Baru (GKB) , Kabupaten Gresik , Jawa Timur, 61121, Indonesia

Author Origin : Indonesia

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

How to Cite

Putra Rahmadhan, R., & Akhmad Wasiur Rizqi. (2026). Analysis of Causes and Risk Mitigation for Delivery Delays Based on On-Time In-Full (OTIF) Data in Non-Cement Distribution Using RCA and FMEA Methods at PT XYZ. International Journal of Science, Technology & Management, 7(6), 757–765. https://doi.org/10.46729/ijstm.v7i6.1522